Hand holding a 4oz block of a squishy butter toy against a white background
A rectangular stick labeled “Salted Butter, 4 oz (113 g)” shown on a white background.
A retail display box of “Butter Squishy Toy” products designed like butter sticks, arranged in rows with farm-themed graphics and cow illustrations on the packaging.
New arrival

Butter Squishy Toy

$7.99
Free Domestic Shipping On Orders $75+
Certified Sweet
Squeeze, squish, and relax with this adorable Butter Squishy Toy! Designed to look like a cute block of butter, this ultra‑soft squishy slowly rises back to shape, making it perfect for stress relief, sensory play, or simple everyday fun. Whether you’re at work, school, or home, this squishy is a satisfying way to calm your hands and mind.
View details

Shop New Arrivals

View all
Quick buy
Butter Squishy Toy
$7.99
Quick buy
Warheads x ZHC Extreme Sour Chewies
$4.99
Quick buy
Warheads Sour Clouds Cotton Candy Chewies
$4.99
Quick buy
KoKo's Candy Hot Pot
$3.99
Quick buy
Care Bears Fuggler Plush Charm Blind Box
$19.99
Quick buy
Hello Kitty & Friends Sanrio Crate Box
$59.99
Quick buy
Keyboard Clicker Keychain
$6.99
Quick buy
One Piece Ocean Blue Raspberry Energy Drink
$3.99
Quick buy
Final Boss Sour Watermelon Kiwis Level 3
$8.99
Quick buy
Sour Boy Pickle Kit Cotton Candy
$26.99
Quick buy
IT'SUGAR Magical Swirl Cotton Candy
$5.99
Quick buy
IT'SUGAR Sour Blue Razz Cotton Candy
$5.99
Quick buy
IT'SUGAR Pink & Blue Cotton Candy
$5.99
Quick buy
AMOS Crystal Gummy Bears
$9.99
Quick buy
AMOS Gummy Crystal Jewels
$9.99
Quick buy
IT'SUGAR Seriously Sour Candy Dust
$4.99
Quick buy
IT'SUGAR Extremely Sour Candy Dust
$4.99
Quick buy
IT'SUGAR Spicy Candy Dust
$4.99
Quick buy
Surprise Squishy Dumplin 3.5in
$9.99
Quick buy
Surprise Sparkle Dumplin 2.25in
$4.99