FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $75

A can-shaped product package for 'Mystery Squishy Sardines' by Keycraft, featuring a blue and white striped design with a yellow fish illustration and a pull tab on the front.

A hand holding an open gray silicone snack pouch, revealing a gold foil-sardine squishy toy, against a plain white background.

A small metallic gold sardine fish-shaped object held between a person's thumb and index finger against a plain white background.

Five translucent fish-shaped stress toys in purple, light blue, yellow, red, and green, arranged on a plain white background.

New arrival

Mystery Sardines Squishy Toy

$7.99

Free Domestic Shipping On Orders $75+

Certified Sweet

Get ready to squish up some seriously fishy fun! The Mystery Sardines Squishy puts a silly spin on snack time with a soft, slow-rising design inspired by everyone’s favorite tiny canned fish. You never know which sardine you’ll get, making every unboxing a surprise! Perfect for collectors, fidget fans, and anyone who likes their squishies a little bit weird. Sardines, but make them squishy!

Mystery Sardines Squishy Toy

Shop New Arrivals

View all

Quick buy

IT'SUGAR Chocolatey Boulders

Quick buy

Big Squij Corgi Butt Squishy Toy

Quick buy

Gummiez Sparkle Kitty Squishy Toy

Quick buy

Dill Pickle Squishy Toy

Quick buy

Jumbo Fortune Cookie Squishy

Quick buy

Mystery Sardines Squishy Toy

Quick buy

Wax Squishies Donut Crackle Fidget Toy

Quick buy

Easy Sqweezy Cake Toy

Quick buy

Potion's Cauldron Serpent's Venom Soda

Quick buy

Potion's Cauldron Witches' Brew Soda

Quick buy

Potion's Cauldron Spellbound Soda

Quick buy

Giant 1LB Reese's Cup

Quick buy

1UP Mash Ups Candy Salad Kit

Quick buy

1UP Blasted Sour Blue Razz Belts

Quick buy

1UP Blasted Sour Rainbow Belts

Quick buy

Nerds Clusters Cherry Lemonade Bag

Quick buy

YOUTOOZ Domo-kun 9in Plush

Quick buy

Amos Chili Mango Gummy Peelerz

Quick buy

NeeDoh Squishmas 2026 Advent Calendar

Quick buy

Jumbo Scented 12" Cheese Squishtible